scrum blog
ESPNscrum Home ESPNscrum Home
Fan Zone
Rumour Mill
Latest News

RSS feed
Editor's Blog

FeedbackFeedback

« England and Ireland gear up for the new season | | RFU enters the 21st Century »

September 21, 2009

Posted on 09/21/2009

Tri-Nations team of the tournament?





A class apart: Springboks skipper John Smit © Getty Images
As the dust settles on the latest Tri-Nations battle it is time to decide on our Team of the Tournament. South Africa coasted to this year's title so not surprisingly they dominate our selection. Let us know your thoughts on our line-up.

15. Frans Steyn (South Africa)
We already knew he could kick the leather off the ball but with three successful kicks from inside his own half against the All Blacks in Hamilton he cemented his reputation as one of the most deadly boots in the game.

14. Cory Jane (New Zealand)
Jane may have only featured twice during this year's Tri-Nations but he did enough against the Wallabies in Wellington to claim a spot in our line-up. There may have been a general lack of top quality wing play but let us not detract from his superb try at the Westpac Stadium. One for the future.

13. Adam Ashley-Cooper (Australia)
There were few bright spots for the Wallabies in this year's Tri-Nations but Ashley-Cooper's emergence as a genuine threat at outside centre was one of them. After stepping into the void left by injured captain Stirling Mortlock, he went on to play a starring role in his side's upset of the Springboks.

12. Jean de Villiers (South Africa)
A close run thing between the Springboks stalwart, Australia's Berrick Barnes and New Zealand's Ma'a Nonu with the latter making a late run at the spot. But it is Munster-bound De Villiers who gets the nod for largely dominating his counterparts with a tight defensive game and a trademark intercept score to wrap up the tournament in Hamilton.

11. Bryan Habana (South Africa)
The ever-impressive Habana took his try tally to 35 from 52 games with a brace against the Wallabies in Perth. Rellatively quiet but still a significant presence.

10. Morne Steyn (South Africa)
New Zealand's Dan Carter may have stolen some headlines with his return to the international stage but make no mistake Steyn was the star of the show. He made his Tri-Nations bow at half-time against the All Blacks in Bloemfontein and didn't look back. He finished with a record 95 points to his name including another record 31 point haul against New Zealand in Durban.

9. Fourie du Preez (South Africa)
Surely a shoe-in for the IRB Player of the Year and that is before the Springboks have even embarked on their end-of-season march through Europe. So often the Springboks' driving force, he is in the form of his life thanks largely to a deadly kicking game.

1. Benn Robinson (Australia)
The Wallabies' loose-head enhanced his growing reputation despite his side's erratic record. Most memorably got the better of Smit in the Wallabies' victory in Brisbane.

2. Bismarck du Plessis (South Africa)
Anchored a dominant Springboks pack and provided plenty of grunt in the loose. And while New Zealand's Andrew Hore and Australia's Tatafu Polota-Nau struggled at lineout time, Du Plessis had the twin towers of Matfield and Botha to rely upon.

3. John Smit (South Africa)
The Springboks skipper has his critics but he has also tasted success at the Rugby World Cup, against the Lions and now in the Tri-Nations. His scrummaging may have been questioned but he was never out of his depth as some would have you believe. A true statesman off the field, he finally shared in a victory on New Zealand soil and is still the best captain in the international game by a long way.

5. Victor Matfield (South Africa) & 4. Bakkies Botha (South Africa)
The Springboks duo are named together for they are such a formidable partnership, a team within a team. Widely regarded as the best second row pairing in the world before this year's Tri-Nations, they cemented that reputation with a physical and mental mauling of their southern hemisphere rivals.

6 (Openside). Heinrich Brussow (South Africa)
Brussow emerged as a world-class talent during the Springboks' series victory over the Lions earlier this year and kicked on again in the Tri-Nations. He continues to boss his more experienced rivals including the likes of All Blacks skipper Richie McCaw and his Wallabies counterpart George Smith.

7 (Blindside). Juan Smith (South Africa)
The silent efficiency of Smith has long been a key part of the Springboks arsenal and he was again at his best until injury brought an end to his campaign. He was unable to share in the delight of the title-clinching victory in Hamilton and will be sorely missed on their end of year tour having subsequently suffered a knee injury.

8. Keiran Read (New Zealand)
The strong-running Kiwi made the most of his opportunity after Rodney So'oialo was cast aside by coach Graham Henry. Expect the 23-year-old to go from strength to strength on the end of year tour.

FeedbackFeedback

Comments

Posted Shaun Porter on 09/22/2009

No McCaw? You've got to be joking right? Brussow hasn't got the big game experience to match him - yet.

Posted Nilanka on 09/22/2009

Personally think Carter and Giteau are talented and earn the spot above Styen.. They haven't had the same class of forwards as SA who dominated breakdown and Steyn made it pay with his boot. He hasn't got the navigation skills as Carter and Giteau yet.. but his time will surely come nearly..

Posted David on 09/22/2009

It's got be Giteau and Barnes at 10 and 12. Steyn is a great kicker, yes, but Giteau gave it his all over the series, and is a far better playmaker at fly-half.

Posted Dean Henderson on 09/23/2009

No McCaw. Yes, that's right. He is completely overrated and needs the ref to turn a blind eye to his cheating in order to have any impact on the game. Brussouw completely showed him up in 3 Tests. Agree that Giteau should be there instead of Steyn, but Ashley-Cooper getting in ahead of Jacque Fourie is a joke.

Posted Motlhabane on 09/23/2009

Jacque Fourie must be in this team as he is was very outstanding in this Tri Nations.

Posted ROG on 09/23/2009

Although not taking part in this tri nations series, Ronan Ogara deserves a mention when discussing world class out halves. Between his boyish good looks, terrifying aggression and animalistic tackling, Ogara continues to strike fear into the hearts of any man foolish enough to run down his channel.

Posted patrcikw on 09/23/2009

Brussow most certainly out played McCaw during this year's Tri Nations, especially in the early tests (and dominated the test series against the B&I Lions prior too it). He did have one poor game in the shocking loss to the Aussies but other than that I believe that he has cemented himself as McCaw's heir apparent and someday will be the best flanker in the game.

Posted patrickw on 09/23/2009

oh, and the post by ROG - HILARIOUS! :)

Posted Justin on 09/23/2009

Must concur about Giteau. He is the only reason the Wallabies are ever in a match. Ashley Cooper was the class of outside center during the tournament and Fourie is overrated. The only people who O'Gara strikes fear in is Lions fans since he blew the series for them.

Posted darklord on 09/24/2009

like this selection, pretty much spot on. The Giteau/Steyn call is tight but you can't ignore Steyn's scoreboard contribution. OK, Giteau is proabably the better player, but Steyn was more valuable over the course of the tournament. Can't believe people are asking for McCAw - did they not watch the games? the great man is in decline (albeit from stratospheric levels of performance). Keiran Read is a bit of a leftfield call, Elsom or Smith could edge in there. Special mention should be made of Bismarck du Blessis, he's the closest a hooker will ever get to being a world star. phenomenal player.

Posted redcrushk on 09/25/2009

Okay, first of all, Ronan Ogara has TERRIBLE tackling. I remember the Wales Ireland Six Nations game, and Wales were CONSTANTLY attacking his channels, and he continued to miss tackles. His blunder in the Lions tour of South Africa was also terrible. Stephen Jones was by far much better than him. As for the Ten's in this category, its hard not to give it to Steyn considering how much damage he did and how many records he broke. But in terms of playmaking, and a running threat, both Cater and Giteau are in a much higher class. I'm starting to be amazed how many tries Matt Giteau scores as a first five-eighth...

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines
 
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left

About
Graham Jenkins joined Scrum in 1999 and took over the reins for a second time in 2006. His journalistic career has also seen him work for BBC Sport and IMG and he currently lives with his family in Farnham. Graham Jenkins
Flickr
www.flickr.com

Upload yours by emailing them to ant75sit@photos.flickr.com

Recent Posts
Categories
Archives
© ESPN EMEA Ltd
espn